COVID-19 Political Fallout — June 2020

Below is a monthly update, marking key metrics and commentary in from mid-May to mid-June, the third month since lockdowns began.

Polling Round Up

According to Gallop tracking polls, the number of Americas who are worried about catching the virus has declined for the second month in a row, from a high of 57% in mid-April to 49% in mid-June. However the drop was only two points this month, compared to 6 points last month. A more significant shift was need in the financial hardship question. Last month the number of Americans somewhat-to-very worried about financial hardship increased five points over the month before. This month that number dropped 9 points. Only 44% are concerned about their personal financial situation, down from 53% last month.

In the fivethirtyeight average of polls, there was a similar decline in the number concerned about catching the virus (64% down 3.7%). On the larger questions of Americans concerned about economy: 84% are some/very concerned, down 1.9% from last month.

Disapproval of Trump’s response continues to climb, with disproval/approval at 54%/42%. The disapproval margin is now 12.1%, up from -9.2% in Mary and -1.1 in April.

Political Weirding

The most significant event this month was the police murder of George Floyd on Memorial Day and the ensuing weeks of protest that brought huge crowds into the streets across the country and sparked debate over how serious the COVID-19 lockdowns and social distancing measures can be going forward.

However, in the week before that, here is some of what the conversation was about:

A New York Times piece on Biden moving toward a more expansive agenda: Democratic leaders say that if they hold power next January, they must be prepared to move to pump trillions more into the economy; enact infrastructure and climate legislation far larger than they previously envisioned; pass a raft of aggressive worker-protection laws; expand government-backed health insurance and create enormous new investments in public-health jobs, health care facilities and child care programs…. “There is a recognition that this event is more transformative than 2008, more transformative than 9/11, more transformative than the fall of the Berlin Wall,” said Senator Mark Warner of Virginia, a centrist Democrat.

The Republican governor of Ohio Mike Dewine wrote this on Twitter Monday May 18: We are marshaling all the resources at our disposal to assemble a large contingent of law enforcement and health officials from across state agencies and from our local communities. We will coordinate with them as part of the Department of Public Safety’s Ohio Investigative Unit. They will surge in to conduct safety compliance checks in crowded bars and restaurants.

Nursing homes where those groups make up a significant portion of the residents — no matter their location, no matter their size, no matter their government rating — have been twice as likely to get hit by the coronavirus as those where the population is overwhelmingly white.

Here is an account of what one New Jersey town is doing to successfully contact trace 90% of their COVID-19 cases.

Early June saw new stages of reopening across the country, including Las Vegas: Vegas reopened casinos over the weekend: Dealers and players are separated by Plexiglas, dice are doused in sanitizer after every throw, and guests, encouraged though not required to wear masks, are subject to mandatory temperature checks.

In NYC, the first phase of reopening began on Monday, with construction cites and retail stores. The case count is low enough “for New York City’s corps of contract tracers, who began work last week, to try to track every close interaction and, officials hope, stop a resurgence of the virus.”

News of increasing case counts in certain states: Since the start of June, 14 states and Puerto Rico have recorded their highest-ever seven-day average of new coronavirus cases since the pandemic began, according to data tracked by The Washington Post: : Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Florida, Kentucky, New Mexico, North Carolina, Mississippi, Oregon, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and Utah.

The second week of June as a time of great (pessimistic) reflection on our collective battle against the virus.

Douthat: With this last turn, we’ve reached the end of the progression, because it means the original theory behind a stern public health response — that the danger to life and health justified suspending even the most righteous pursuits, including not just normal economic life but the practices and institutions that protect children, comfort the dying, serve the poor — has been abandoned or subverted by every faction in our national debate. … [which] does signal that there will be no further comprehensive attempt to fight the virus. Trump and conservatism won’t support it, the public health bureaucracy won’t be able to defend it, and we didn’t use the time the lockdowns bought to build the infrastructure to sustain a campaign of actual suppression.

Writing in The Atlantic: These numbers all reflect infections that likely began before this week of protest. An even larger spike now seems likely. Put another way: If the country doesn’t see a substantial increase in new COVID-19 cases after this week, it should prompt a rethinking of what epidemiologists believe about how the virus spreads…. If so, it won’t be because the United States made concerted, coordinated decisions about how to balance the horrors of the pandemic and the frustration of pausing everyday life. Instead, the United States has moved from attempting to beat the virus to managing the harm of losing.

Week 175: May 24-30

America hit 100,000 deaths on Wednesday May 27.

Trump got pushback from some allies for continuing to tweet accusations that Joe Scarborough killed an aide in the 90s.

Pressure was put on Twitter to delete the tweets, which they declined to do.

The widow sent a letter to Twitter’s CEO asking him to take down the tweet: “I’m asking you to intervene in this instance because the president of the United States has taken something that does not belong to him — the memory of my dead wife — and perverted it for perceived political gain.” They declined to do so.They declined. However, they did start fact checking Trump’s tweets.

Trump responded with an Executive Order limiting liability protections for social media companies.

George Floyd was killed by strangulation by police on Monday, Memorial Day, setting off protests that spread across the country throughout the week.

Twitter blocked a Trump tweet for violating its rules.

Here is the tweet: ….These THUGS are dishonoring the memory of George Floyd, and I won’t let that happen. Just spoke to Governor Tim Walz and told him that the Military is with him all the way. Any difficulty and we will assume control but, when the looting starts, the shooting starts. Thank you!

More on Trump’s looting/shooting tweet here.

Here is a gut-check by a New York Times critic on the fake censorship Trump has been complaining about from Twitter, and the actual censorship of a black CNN reporter who was arrested on camera by police in Minneapolis.

In Russia News

Friday night a record of Flynn’s 2016 calls with Kislyak were leaked.

COVID-19 cases / deaths: 1,719,827 / 101,711

Trump’s Job Approval: 42.6%

Week 174: May 17-23

Washington Post reports on the State Department IG firing: “I have learned that there may be another reason for Mr. Linick’s firing,” Rep. Eliot L. Engel (D-N.Y.), the chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee, said in a statement sent to me. “His office was investigating — at my request — Trump’s phony declaration of an emergency so he could send weapons to Saudi Arabia.”

This is connected to this story by the New York Times which came out over the weekend about the Saudi arms deals.

The IG had also “begun an inquiry into Mr. Pompeo’s possible misuse of a political appointee to perform personal tasks for him and his wife, according to Democratic aides. That included walking the dog, picking up dry-cleaning and making restaurant reservations, one said — an echo of the whistle-blower complaint from last year.”

Here is a line from a New York Times piece on intelligence briefings for Trump: Mr. Trump rarely absorbs information that he disagrees with or that runs counter to his worldview, the officials said. Briefing him has been so great a challenge compared with his predecessors that the intelligence agencies have hired outside consultants to study how better to present information to him.

The Trump Administration withdrew from a key arms control accord.

More family separation of immigrants are happening. Here is more from a New York Times report.

COVID-19 Cases / Deaths: 1,595,885 / 96,002

Trump’s Job Approval: 42.9%

The 20th Trump Job Approval Dip

Episode 20

Rank: 4

Decline: -2.40%

Lowest Approval: 43.4%

Date Range: April 4-25, 2020

Key Events: COVID-19

Trump Pivot 3: Trump and Task Force first admits over 100,000 may die. “It’s absolutely critical for the American people to follow the guidelines for the next 30 days. It’s a matter of life and death.”; a lot fo talk about urgent need for testing, including Trump downplaying need in the states, and reporting on why testing was delayed due to FDA/CDC mistakes; Trump reversal of call for Easter opening; Navy captain fired for Covid-19 help request; CDC says Americans should wear face masks; Highest daily death count yet; jobless claims at 16 million, rising to 26 million; Round of major papers writing about poor Trump response in early days of the pandemic; daily press briefings continue, making Republicans nervous about Trump’s performance; Trump Pivot 4: blame shifting and push to re-open the country by May 1; failed business group task force; small business loan ran out of money; small lock down protests are first held; Trump road-testing an anti-lockdown message; Senate renews money for small business loan; some states are easing lockdowns; House passed new stimulus; Trump’s daily press briefings continue, and on 4/23 he says UV light or disinfectants might be used to kill the virus internally; talk of ending the press briefings over the weekend.

This dip–relatively low compared to the other 19 dips–is the result of two factors happening simultaneously: 1) the swift deflation of the temporary approval spike to 45.8% that corresponded with the onset of the crisis; 2) a negative news cycle going into the second month of national lockdowns where there was a lot of discussion of early missteps that got us to this point. When Trump was at his high point mentioned above there were only 1,246 dead, but by the end of this dip there were 48,816 dead.

This dip brings him closer to his homeostasis point fo 42-43%, where he has been for much of the second half of his term. The dip stalled out at around 43% for the next 4 weeks. At which point events in May and June brought on the 21st approval dip…